Saturday, 14 May 2011

Ants, Treehoppers and Butterflies: Mutualistic Mutualisms?

One of the major problems facing an insect herbivore is finding a safe area on plant tissue in order to feed. Abundant predators such as ants can often supplement their liquid diets of nectar with herbivorous insects, thus posing a constant threat. Despite this some insects actively attract ants for their own benefit forming an association known as Myrmecophily.

One such group of insects, the treehoppers, feed on plant sap and excrete honeydew. This attracts ants that feed on this rich sugary liquid and in turn act as ‘bodyguards’ for the treehoppers, warding off enemies such as spiders and wasps. This specific relationship, in which one organism protects another in exchange for food, is known as trophobiosis. The relationship is mutualistic, in that it benefits both the treehoppers and the ants.


G. xiphias with their ant 'bodyguards'P.pilobetes laying eggs on S. vinosa, arrow
indicates curved abdomen tip

Many butterfly species also exploit this relationship, preferring plants that have ant attractants, such as nectary glands, or those that already house ant colonies on which to lay their eggs. One such species which takes advantage of this association is Parrhasius polibetes. During the early stages of development, the caterpillars (larvae) of this butterfly use various methods to pacify or hide from the ants until a nectar organ becomes operational. Once the caterpillar can produce nectar, the ‘bodyguard’ relationship with the ant can be formed.

Kaminski et al. wanted to investigate the possibility that the presence of honeydew producing treehoppers and ants, in a trophobiotic relationship, may influence the host-plant selection of P. polibetes for egg laying (in order to subsequently increase caterpillar survival). Selection of a host housing this treehopper/ant association may benefit the butterfly by:

1) Creating a predator free space around the caterpillars during their early vulnerable states.
2) Increasing the chance of the caterpillar being discovered by prospective ‘bodyguard’ ants because they  are already nearby.

The host plant Schefflera vinosa was used to conduct the study, along with the treehopper Guayaquila xiphias, which is often found on these shrubs. Tests were conducted in branch pairs, in which one branch was occupied by the treehoppers/ants and the other branch was unoccupied. Ants and other insects were excluded from unoccupied branches by the application of resin at branch bases. Trials were conducted in the field during a period of high P. polibetes abundance. Experiments were conducted on egg-laying preference and caterpillar survival. The authors also performed the same experiments whereby ants could access both branches but treehoppers only occupied one branch.

Results revealed a tendency for P. polibetes females to lay eggs, and to lay higher numbers of eggs, on branches housing the treehopper/ant association (compared to unoccupied branches). This is an important discovery, being one of the first studies to produce evidence that a treehopper/ant association can influence the behavioural decisions of P. polibetes. It was also noted that caterpillars were three times more likely to survive in the presence of treehoppers, rather than relying solely on their own ability to attract ants.

The exact nature of the signal that influences the egg-laying decisions of P. polibetes was not identified however host selection by plant feeding insects is carried out by the adult females and is often related to the survival and growth of their young.

This study highlights the importance of considering the multiple interactions that occur on a plant host. The butterflies are taking advantage of the treehoppers ability to attract ants but perhaps the treehoppers also benefit from the extra ants attracted by P. polibetes thus forming ‘mutualistic mutualisms’

References (note a login may be required for some journals)

Kaminski, L.A., Freitas, A.V.L., Oliveira, P.S. 2010. Interaction between mutualisms: Ant-tended butterflies exploit enemy-free space provided by ant-treehopper associations. The American Naturalist, 176, 322-334 (DOI: 10.1086/655427)

Thompson, J.N. Pellmyr, O. 1991. Evolution of oviposition behaviour and host preference in Lepidoptera. Annual Review of Entomology 36, 65-89 (DOI: 10.1146/annurev.en.36.010191.000433).

Malicky, H. 1970. New aspects on the association between lycaenid larvae (Lycaenidae) and ants (Formicidae, Hymenoptera). Journal of the Lepidopterists’ Society 24, 190-202 (PDF)

6 comments:

  1. What sort of ant are they??
    Are they especially ferocious in anyway or do they rely on power in numbers to fend off predators??

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Jade, for the study two species of ants were used, Camponotus rufipes and Camponotus renggeri as they behave very aggressively towards intruders and 'hog' the trehoppers to themselves. Apparently around 20 ant species can form the relationship with these treehoppers. It was not really discussed how these different ant species may interact with each other.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Jackie,
    I have just posted a blog on fireants. While researching them I found they do the same. They protect and care for the scale insect to use the honeydew however if food gets short they will also eat the insect!! It is an interesting subject.How many other species could benefit? Does it carry on to the next trophic level of predators of the butterfly?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Jenny, it was also mentioned in this paper that the ants will eat insects if short of food, I wonder at what point they decide that there is not enough honeydew and eat the insect instead? It would be interesting to see a study that examined all species affected by these interactions and how they impact each other.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I reiterate a point I made elsewhere - ants are gangsters. Are there any harmless ants out there?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Ben, they are harmless when things are going well and they are in a good mood!!, I am sure thay are just misunderstood....

    ReplyDelete