Thursday, 28 April 2011

The first fossil record of insect behavioural manipulation?

Fossils are the preserved remains of animals and plants that provide us with precious glimpses of ancient life on earth. Insect fossils are relatively scarce as their thin waterproof shell (exoskeleton) is unable to withstand preservation in many oxygenated environments. The exception to this is in amber (hardened tree sap) in which perfect specimens showing minute detail have been discovered. Insect behaviour such as feeding and leaf mining has been recorded on fossilized leaves and evidence of parasitic fungi on insect hosts has been noted in the fossil record. What has not previously been discovered is fossilised evidence of insect behavioural modification.

Fungus protruding from the head of a dead ant.
Parasites often manipulate host behaviour in order to promote their own fitness. A striking example of this type of behaviour manipulation is that between the fungus Ophiocordyceps unilateralis and its worker ant host. The fungus enters the ant through small breathing holes located along its body (spiracles). It initially uses non-essential tissues as a food source and then, when ready to reproduce, it enters the ant’s brain to alter its behaviour.

The manipulation is very precise. Ants leave the upper canopy of forests (greater than 20 meters) descending to around 25 cm above the forest floor. This location provides optimum conditions (humidity/temperature) for fungal growth.

The ants attach to major veins on the undersides of leaves with their mandibles in a ‘death grip’ and are subsequently killed. The fungus then grows a stalk out of the ants head (bearing an egg shaped structure) from which its spores are released to infect other ants.

Fossil leaf with ant death-grip scars
The Messel Pit in Hesse, Germany is a UNESCO world heritage site noted for the number of rare fossils that have been unearthed in exceptional condition. A fossilised leaf, dated around 48 million years old, was discovered at this site bearing distinctive scars surrounding the leaf veins. Two scientists, Conrad Labandeira from the Smithsonian Institute in Washington and Torsten Wappler from the Steinmann Institute in Germany, had been trying to establish what had caused the distinctive marks on the leaf. They were contacted by a behavioural ecologist called David P. Hughes, who had been conducting fieldwork in Thailand on the infection of Camponotus leonardi (carpenter ants) by fungal parasites resulting in behaviour modification.

The fossil was examined microscopically and compared to numerous photographs taken with a microscope of leaf scars left by specimens of infected C. leonardi from Thailand. Based on these comparisons it is concluded that the first fossilised record of insect behavioural manipulation has been found.

Conclusions were based on the following:
  1. The leaf bore very distinctive dumbbell-shaped cut marks. The closest modern comparison to this distinctive type of leaf marking is that of C. leonardi infected by O. unilateralis in Thailand. The marking is caused by a pair of puncture marks surrounded by calloused tissue.
  2. The ant bites are not randomly placed but centred on major veins
  3. The choice of host plant (leaf) is non-selective and based strongly on favourable environmental conditions for the fungal parasite
Hughes also concluded that the marks are not caused by other ants / beetles cutting veins during feeding as “It is not normal ant behavior to bite into the leaf vein because it has no real nutritional value to the ant and can in fact be toxic in some plant species,” [Nature].

Whilst there have been no fossilised species of Camponotus found at Messel there have been specimens found in Baltic amber from Germany and also in amber from Ukraine indicating they may have existed in the ancient Messel environment.

References (note a login may be required for some journals)

Hughes, D.P., Wappler, T., & Labandeira, C. (2011). Ancient death-grip leaf scars reveal ant-fungal parasitism. Biology Letters, 7(1), 67-70. (doi: 10.1098/rsbl.2010.0521)

Anderson, S.B., Gerritsma, S., Yusah, K.M., Mayntz, D., Hywel-Jones, N.L.,Billen, J.,Boomsma, J.J., & Hughes, D.P. (2009). The life of a dead ant: the expression of an adaptive extended phenotype. The American Naturalist, 174, 424-433. (doi: 10.1086/603640)

2 comments:

  1. What really strikes me as weird is how many marks are on that one leaf - imagine how loaded with zombie ants the whole tree would have been

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Ben, its pretty amazing isn't it, apparently there were 29 death grip scars on the leaf on 11 leaf veins. Can't even begin to imagine how many must have been on the whole tree, although I guess they would have been on the lower leaves only.

    ReplyDelete